@drewmurr2,
Date-Time support for Y-axis is not available as of now. But as you said, with the help of time-stamp and labelFormatter, you can achieve date-time over y-axis. Please check this jsfiddle.
Another way to achieve this is by rotating the chart-container div with chart axisX as date-time and setting axisYType to secondary. Please refer this jsfiddle.
—
Vishwas R